Early Tomato Comparison-2018

It’s time for the potager’s early tomato comparison featuring this year’s competitors:   last year’s winning “Polbig” and this year’s challenger, “Siletz.”  Both were seeded and handled identically, and planted out the same dates, same number of plants (8), etc.   “Polbig” is a hybrid determinate from Pinetree Seeds, who said it “sets fruit in cool weather, tastes good with excellent dark red color inside and out, between 3 1/2 and 6 oz per fruit.  56 days.”  I would add that it has good disease resistance and a very meaty interior with fewer seeds than many varieties.  Even my mother, a faithful “Rutgers” fan for 70 years asked for some “Polbig” plants again this year, after having them the past two.  The total season production weight comparison is Polbig 33.75 pounds; Siletz, 18 pounds, but it was the quality of the fruit that made “Polbig” the big winner for the third year in a row.  It’s the one on the right, obviously bigger.Tomato comparison 2

“Siletz” is from Seeds N Such, who writes “the best combination of extreme earliness and big, slicer-type fruits.  Mature in only 52 days with big, deep red 8-10 oz fruits that are tasty and nearly seedless.  Determinate.”  “Siletz” did produce the first full-size (that is, not cherry-size)  ripe tomato on July 9, while the first “Polbig” wasn’t ripe until July 15.  Overall “Siletz” fruit was slightly smaller in size, but many of them had cracks and splits around the tops and didn’t make it to the kitchen.  None of mine were in the 8-10 oz range, but they did have good flavor.  However, they were done producing on August 13 so the vines were pulled.  “Polbig” continued to produce nice-sized ripe fruit for another week, with several less than ripe and green tomatoes going into chutney.  The space was needed for late cabbages!

So, obviously “Polbig” will be planted next year, along with another contender.  If you want to suggest a candidate, please comment!

About carolee

A former professional herb and lavender grower, now just growing for joy in my new potager. When I'm not in the garden, I'm in the kitchen, writing, or traveling to great gardens.
This entry was posted in tomatoes, Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

11 Responses to Early Tomato Comparison-2018

  1. Oh, yum! I could eat a tomato right now.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I love reading your reviews of vegetables. I need to start being more selective on the varieties I grow. 🙂


    • carolee says:

      It’s the record-keeping that makes the true difference. I “knew” that I liked the quality of the Polbigs better, but I was surprised at the difference in poundage. Had the production weights been lots closer, I might have planted “Siletz” again just because it was earlier and that’s what my mind recalled. Now I’ll be looking for a different early variety that I haven’t tried to compete with Polbig…just for the fun of it!

      Liked by 1 person

  3. bcparkison says:

    the best tasting tomato I ever grew was Brandywine. Wonderful.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s